Cutover vs Staged Migration: Choosing the Right Strategy

5 min read Updated on December 1, 2024 Cloudiway Team

Overview

The right migration plan for your organization will depend on the technical, business, and cultural factors at play. There are two primary approaches to data migration: cutover and staged. Understanding the benefits and trade-offs of each helps you make the best choice for your situation.

Cutover

Everyone moves at once, typically over a weekend

Staged

Users migrate in batches over weeks or months

Cutover Migration

A cutover migration involves moving all mailboxes simultaneously, typically over a weekend. This is the fastest, simplest form of migration.

How It Works

  1. Pre-stage data by running migration passes before cutover
  2. On cutover day, run final delta pass
  3. Switch DNS/MX records to target
  4. All users immediately access the new system
  5. New emails route to the target system right away

Benefits

Simplicity

No need for complex coexistence configurations

Speed

Fastest overall migration timeline

Clear Cutover Date

Everyone knows exactly when the transition happens

Reduced Complexity

No split-brain scenarios or routing confusion

Best For

  • Organizations with fewer than 500-1000 users
  • Teams with weekend migration windows available
  • Companies wanting minimal coexistence overhead
  • Migrations with straightforward data volumes

Pre-staging Strategy

You can combine cutover with pre-staging by running multiple migration passes before the final cutover weekend. This reduces the amount of data that needs to transfer during the critical window.

Staged Migration

A staged migration distributes mailbox migration across weeks or months, moving users in batches. This approach offers flexible migration strategies when using the Cloudiway platform.

How It Works

  1. Plan batches by department, location, or other criteria
  2. Set up coexistence (mail routing, GALSync, Free/Busy)
  3. Migrate batch 1, verify, communicate to users
  4. Repeat for subsequent batches
  5. Final batch completes, disable coexistence

Benefits

Extended Timeline

Reduces pressure with no single critical deadline

Flexible Batching

Migrate according to organizational needs and priorities

Selective Migration

Choose what, who, and when to migrate

Risk Mitigation

Issues affect smaller groups, easier to resolve

Best For

  • Large organizations (1000+ users)
  • Organizations unable to complete migration in one weekend
  • Complex scenarios requiring minimal user disruption
  • Companies with large data volumes
  • Mergers where organizational integration is phased

Planning Required

Staged migrations demand more thorough planning than single-pass cutover approaches. You'll need to configure coexistence services and manage user communication carefully.

Choosing Your Strategy

Consider these factors when deciding between cutover and staged migration:

Factor Cutover Staged
Organization Size < 1000 users 1000+ users
Data Volume Moderate Large
Complexity Simple Higher
Planning Effort Lower Higher
Coexistence Needed No Yes
Risk Exposure All at once Distributed

Flexible Platform

Cloudiway enables both cutover and staged migration strategies, along with coexistence services and customizable batching to support whatever approach works best for your organization.

Was this article helpful?

Need more help? Contact our support team

We value your feedback

Help us improve your experience

What would you like to share with us?

Need direct support? Open a ticket